"> Impacts of Mergers & Acquisitions on Shareholder Wealth – Course Writing Pals

Impacts of Mergers & Acquisitions on Shareholder Wealth

This argument attempts to investigate, the appulse of Mergers & Accretion (M&A) on actor abundance in the European cyberbanking industry from 2003-2007 and explains in abyss detail of the abstract advised by the columnist to accommodate the abject of the acknowledged accomplishment of the project. M&A has been a accepted assay affair in accounts with ample abstract exists on M&A. For this assay to be achievable, a ample chase for advice was undertaken by bureau of the internet and library. The assay catechism will appraise the abundance furnishings (abnormal returns) of M&A involving European banks application `event study` alignment over the aeon of 2003-2007 in both the advertisement aeon and continued run column accretion period. In addition words, can M&A improves or abort actor abundance of the targets, bidders and accumulated firms.

1.2 Introduction

The decade of 1990 saw the bigger admission in European M&A activity. Alliance & Acquisitions (M&A) accept been a cogent abnormality in the Europe. and the apple abridgement which symbolizes one of the best important cardinal decisions fabricated by managers and shareholders of the affianced firm. Sudarsanam (2003,para1,p.1) argues shareholders and managers may be the best important stakeholders in M&A but addition groups such as workers, competitors, lenders, barter all accept a aggregate absorption in this activity.

M&A may be undertaken in adjustment to alter an inefficient management, but sometimes two businesses may be added admired calm than apart. Motivation abaft the mergers is to maximise the shareholders wealth. However, according to Jensen and Ruback (1983) and Sirower and O`byrne (1998), in about two third of cases, mergers aftermath abundance assets for ambition shareholders and added or beneath aught assets to acquirers. Assorted studies accept begin that, usually the advertisement of coffer mergers neither actualize nor abort shareholders bulk Pilloff and Santomero (1998). Also, some studies indicates that the advertisement of assertive types of coffer mergers do actualize value, if that alliance abate costs.

Berger, Demsetz, Strahan (1999) articular bristles axiological activating factors that actuate accumulated takeovers i.e. an admission of globalization, abstruse progress, cyberbanking deregulation, changes in chump appeal and the affiliation of cyberbanking markets. Arnold (2005, para2, p.1041), authentic mergers as the accumulation of two business entities beneath accepted buying admitting Bruner (2005) states it as alliance of two firms that creates a new article in the eyes of the law.

According to Investorwords.com accretion is a accepting ascendancy of a corporation, alleged a target, by banal acquirement or exchange, either `hostile` or `friendly` which additionally be alleged takeover. E.g. in October 2007, Royal coffer of Scotland (RBS) alloyed with Dutch coffer ABN Amro to assure Europe’s bigger anytime cyberbanking takeover with 86% of ABN Amro’s shareholders accepting a 71bn euro (Ft.com). Bruner (2005) argues takeover activities are cardinal affairs that could about-face out to be an accomplished advance of basic and resources.

1.3Merger waves

Nowadays, M&A is able-bodied accepted actuality that comes in after-effects according to affirmation from Bruner (2005), Gorton, Kahl & Rosen (2005), Martynova & Renneboog (2006). Five alone alliance after-effects were empiric in the UK abridgement in the aftermost aeon i.e. 1900`s, the 1960`s, the 1970`s, the 1980`s and the 1990`s. (Kastrinaki, Stoneman 2007)

Brankman, Garretsen, Van Marrewijk (2008) argues that, in agreement of bread-and-butter importance, the ascendant alliance beachcomber capricious is the absolute all-around outcome, suggesting that M&A after-effects are an abridgement advanced all-around phenomenon. The beachcomber of coffer mergers has been accustomed to explain the assorted theories e.g. the `efficiency hypothesis` apprehend that mergers advance adeptness and advice poor banks to survive as antagonism becomes added accurate in the cyberbanking industry. Gugler, Mueller, Yurtoglu (2004) finds that alliance after-effects can be absolute if one analyze that M&A do not addition adeptness and doesn’t admission shareholders` abundance but instead sited that M&A after-effects are best appear beyond as the acknowledgment of overvalued shares and authoritative opinion.

1.4Why do M&A occur?

In assorted European countries, mergers accept accustomed banks to admission adeptness by acceptable the allocation of the closing of branches. Banks shareholders and managers charge to admit the abeyant sources of bread-and-butter accretion emerged from M&A. Banks can abate costs and admission bulk in altered bureau e.g. diversification. I.e. if mergers accomplish bulk synergies such as economies of scale, banks can abate expenses.

According to affirmation from Berkovitch & Narayanan (1993), Sudarsanam, Holl & Salami (1996), Hannan & Pilloff (2006), Martynova & Renneboog (2006), the motives for M&A accept been categorised into the three basic groups’ i.e. bread-and-butter motive or synergy, authoritative or bureau problems and hubris. The absolute administration of alliance assets amid ambition and applicant shareholders will depend on their alone negotiating strengths. Therefore, afterward table shows the appulse of mergers on shareholders wealth:

Merger Motive

Total Gains

Target Gains

Bidder Gains





Agency problems





1.4.1 Synergy Motive

The aboriginal key accumulation that accounts for M&A is an bread-and-butter or synergy motive which bureau that two companies can accomplish calm which they can’t accomplish single-handedly. Siems (1996) argued that synergy approach projected that the accepting coffer can calmly actualize synergies via economies of calibration and ambit by abbreviation costs and eliminating redundancies and duplication.

Economies of calibration occurs back the boilerplate assemblage bulk of assembly declines as aggregate increases e.g. cyberbanking mergers in the UK of Coffer of Scotland and Halifax of 30bn alliance in May 2001, to actualize HBOS fifth above force in UK cyberbanking sector. The abstraction was that the Coffer of Scotland was operating in arctic of the country and Halifax was in south by amalgamation these two banks, were aggravating to abate bulk of processing cyberbanking transactions. Economies of ambit occurs back the bulk of bearing several articles in a multi artefact close is lower than the bulk of bearing the aforementioned articles by alone firms e.g. Banc affirmation model, British cyberbanking and arising behemothic Lloyds TSB acquired Scottish Widows in June 1999 for 7bn.

Sudarsanam et al (1996) articular the sources of bulk conception into three basic type’s i.e. operational synergy, authoritative synergy and cyberbanking synergy. Operational synergy occurs during the acceptance of economies of calibration and scope, vertical integration, the abolishment of alike activities, the alteration of adeptness or abilities by the bidder’s administration aggregation and a abridgement in bureau costs by bringing alignment absolute assets beneath accepted buying (Ravenscraft & Scherer 1987, 1989 cited in Martynova & Renneboog 2006).

Sources of bulk in vertical mergers includes abbreviation transaction costs in which accumulation altered stages of the assembly alternation can abate costs of advice and acceding i.e. one company’s achievement is addition company’s ascribe and by putting calm will accomplish the business efficient. E.g. Microsoft bid for Yahoo in January 2008, annual $42bn that will actualize added able browser or accept a bigger adventitious of arrest the internet chase leader. Accepting said that, accepted trends appear outsourcing advance that, the allowances from vertical mergers are limited. According to Martynova & Renneboog (2006), establishments of operating synergies abate assembly & administration costs and acquiescent an incremental banknote breeze accruing to the company’s post-merger shareholders.

Sudarsanam et al (1996) argues authoritative synergy could action if the applicant has a competent authoritative aggregation and takes over a ambition with beneath competent managers. Such takeover is antidotal and acceptable to advance the abundance accretion for both applicant and ambition shareholders. Accepting said that, there is a ample accident of bureau problems area the managers do not accomplish in the absorption of shareholders.

Martynova & Renneboog (2006) argues that diversifying takeovers are acceptable to accretion from cyberbanking synergies in which cyberbanking synergies may absorb bigger banknote breeze stability, cheaper admission to capital, an centralized basic bazaar as able-bodied as application efficiencies created by a abridgement in managers’ application risk. Conglomerate mergers acquiesce accident about-face by overextension the assets beck of the captivation aggregation over a advanced array of articles and markets. Sudarsanam et al (1996) finds that cyberbanking synergy actualize from three acceptable sources i.e. the tax advantage of bare debt, the advance opportunities and cyberbanking assets of the arising companies and the coinsurance of debt of the two companies which aftereffect in lower costs of capital.

1.4.2 Bureau bureau

The added basic motive for M&A is authoritative or bureau factor. Shareholders are Principals i.e. owners of company’s assets and managers are active as shareholders’ Agents to administer these assets on their behalf. Managers should accomplish decisions that are constant with the cold of aerate the actor wealth, but managers do not allotment this cold necessarily. Managers will accept their own claimed objectives which will be mainly anxious with maximizing their own welfare (Sudarsanam et al 1996). Therefore, authoritative decisions in acquisitions may aftereffect in abettor costs that abate the absolute bulk of the collective close as they do not maximise but abate shareholders return.

Berger, Demsetz, Strahan (1999) argues that one authoritative ambition may be empire-building. Executive advantage leads to admission with company’s size, so managers may ambition to accomplish claimed cyberbanking assets by agreeable in M&A, although at atomic in allotment the college empiric advantage of the managers of beyond institutions rewards greater accomplishment and effort. To assure their firm-specific animal capital, some managers may additionally try to abate defalcation accident beneath the akin i.e. in shareholders’ absorption possibly by diversifying accident through M&A movement. Arnold (2005) observes that the managers may adore the adventure of the alliance action itself and as a aftereffect advance for such deals to booty place.

1.4.3 Airs

The third and final basic motive for M&A is Airs which was defined by Richard Roll in 1986. Arnold (2005, para2, p.1055), ascertain airs as over weaning cocky aplomb or, beneath kindly, arrogance. The airs antecedent states that the appraisal of ambition by the applicant administration is over optimistic and per se the behest firm’s administration overpays for the target. This conceivably for a cardinal of bases such as decisions makers assertive themselves, that the bulk exists back it does not or that their appraisal is actual and that the bazaar is not ablaze the abounding bread-and-butter bulk of the accumulated firm. These managers may conceivably be brash or accept confused acceptance in their adeptness to advance the accumulation achievement of the ambition firm. Berkovitch & Narayanan (1993) argues that the airs maintains that accommodation makers in the behest firms artlessly pay too abundant for their targets as a aftereffect of mistakes in overestimating the bulk of the targets.

1.5 Factors influencing actor returns

Shareholders allotment are not aloof afflicted by M&A announcements, but they are additionally afflicted by bid characteristics e.g. adjustment of payment, cantankerous bound M&A, affable vs. adverse bids etc.

1.5.1 Adjustment of acquittal

The adjustment of acquittal is one of the key variables that charge be agreed amid the applicant and agent to actuate the firms` aberrant allotment and all-embracing aftereffect of the bid. According to Huang and Walkling (1989), The anatomy of acquittal will access behest action if it affects the advancing NPVs of an acquisition. Huang and Walkling begin that back adjustment of acquittal and bulk of battle were taken into annual statistically, aberrant allotment were no college in breakable offers than in mergers. Acquittal methods can affect NPVs through interrelations with either accretion bulk or the anticipation of success or both admitting Dube, Glascock & Romero (2007) argues that the altered stages of account growing to the ambition and accepting firm’s shareholders is attributed to the addition methods of payments.

Arnold (2005, para1, p.1059) states that banknote acquittal has been the best accepted and best admired adjustment of acquittal which offers college acknowledgment than equity. For example, behest close is accepted to backpack out banal financed alliance if the administration of behest close has better-quality central advice that the absolute assets of the close are overvalued. However, if the applicant close has arcane advice about the ambition aggregation and trusts it to be undervalued, again it apparently action banknote financed merger.

Therefore, alliance financed with stocks are a abrogating arresting because the use of stocks as a adjustment of acquittal is added acceptable to action back the banal is overvalued, while the use of banknote is taken as the close actuality overvalued. Alternatively, if ambition shareholders accede that their coffer is overvalued, they will adopt to accept cash. This approach is accurate by empiric abstract and it demonstrates that at the time of the bid advertisement acquirers who adduce cash, tend to convenance college aberrant allotment than those who action banal financed merger.

The advantage of banknote is that the acquirer shareholders authority the aforementioned akin of ascendancy over their aggregation because their admeasurement of buying has not been adulterated by giving ambition shareholders banal options in the alloyed company. Therefore, the allotment to the shareholders of a behest close will be college in banknote financed alliance than the stock. Brealey, Myers & Marcus (2004, para1, p.599) states if banknote is offered, the bulk of the alliance is not afflicted by the admeasurement of the alliance gains. And if banal is offered, the bulk depends on the assets because the assets appearance up in the column alliance allotment price, and these shares are acclimated to pay for the acquired firm.

1.5.2 Cantankerous bound M&A

The aggregate of common cyberbanking markets has been activity calm with, increases in the cardinal and tiny admeasurement of firms that accomplish in the all-around bazaar and the globalization action has been to a rational admeasurement encouraged by cantankerous bound M&A. According to Brankman, Garretsen, Van Marrewijk (2005, 2008) cross bound M&A are the basic boilerplate for adopted absolute investment. M&A provides axiological but additionally bound compassionate of this anatomy of takeover, as cross-border M&A are best acceptable accompanying to economy-wide shocks such as bread-and-butter integration, changes in the acknowledged and authoritative ambiance or acceptable agee business cycles.

Based on accomplished empiric evidence, admitting the majority of the calm M&A actualize cogent abundance assets for the targets and abrogating or aught allotment for bidders, cantankerous bound M&A could accept altered appulse on accompanying firms. Kang (1993) declared that cantankerous bound M&A are accepted to actualize added abundance than calm ones because of actuality of bazaar imperfections which leads to adviser bunch firms (MNC) accepting a aggressive advantage over bounded firms. Adopted banks accept to act in accordance with with both regulations at home and abroad; calm acclaim establishments accept bulk advantages, back accomplishing two assorted sets of adjustment accomplish added costs on adopted banks.

Also, altered regulations abate the bulk of accompanying anchored costs. This decreases the achievability for banks to aggregate allowances from economies of calibration and scope. Economies of calibration adduce that coffer is able to abate its costs by growing the aggregate of achievement of articles and casework it already produces. As a aftereffect of developing into new country, a coffer increases its abeyant applicant abject and allowances from economies of scale. According to economies of scope, banks that alter activities could abate costs by accouterment added services.

1.5.3 Affable vs. adverse bids

Analysis apropos the appulse of adverse takeovers has been arguable, capricious from the allowances of bazaar conduct for maximizing able appliance of assets to the accident of bazaar shortsightedness on the economy, on the association and on bulk congenital over years. Dube, Glascock & Romero (2007) argues such debates can appulse cyberbanking marketsand can be accepted to aggrandize as developing markets accessible up to adopted corporations and as bread-and-butter ability is redistributed amidst countries. Adverse takeovers occur, back the administration of a close resists the takeover attack by bidders. Lambrecht and Myers (2007) accompaniment that in some cases a potentially adverse acquirer could be bigger off negotiating with the ambition administration for a alliance and that such a bearings reduces the ability of the ambition actor to abstract bulk from the bidder. Adverse acquisitions additionally absorb swifter and added desperate changes in target. In both affable and adverse acquisitions, overpayment can appear due to bureau absorption of authoritative cold access by the acquirer management.

Goergen and Renneboog (2003) analyzed the bazaar reactions to the altered types of takeovers i.e. friendly, adverse and bids with assorted bidders. They begin that adverse bids created the better aberrant allotment for the ambition i.e. 13% on the advertisement day. Back a adverse bid is made, the allotment bulk of the ambition beeline abroad reflects the apprehension that action to the bid will adviser to advancement revisions of the action price. Assorted empiric studies accept begin that the allotment to bidders in adverse takeovers are negative; constant in low achievability of success of a adverse bid.

1.6 Appulse of M&A on shareholders

Almost all of the studies of M&A in cyberbanking industry are based on US data. As we know, one of the basic objectives of mergers is to maximise the shareholders bulk by the bureau of admission in assets and admission in allotment prices, so the shareholders can adore the basic gains. The two best important methods which can be acclimated to appraise the appulse of M&A were explained by Firth in 1980. In the aboriginal method, accounting advice is acclimated to actuate the firms` cyberbanking achievement & profitability. The added adjustment believes in able bazaar which can be acclimated in allotment bulk movements to appraisal the bread-and-butter appulse of the event. The added method, absolute measures any admission or abridgement in shareholders abundance but additionally acquaintance from the absoluteness that no bazaar is absolutely able which after-effects to mislead abstracts due to movement in allotment price.

In this project, columnist chose the added adjustment i.e. an accident abstraction in which the focal point will be on three altered sets e.g. the target, the applicant and the appulse of M&A on accumulated close in the continued run. Assorted empiric studies on M&A accept concentrated on establishing banal bazaar acknowledgment about the advertisement of a accord and whether a alliance creates bulk for the shareholders of ambition and behest firm.

Delong (2001) advised 56 banks amid 1991 and 1995, for absorption mergers that actualize absolute aberrant allotment admitting diversifying mergers aftermath abrogating aberrant returns. DeLong (2001) has point out that aloft advertisement the bazaar responds absolutely to mergers that focus both on the activities and geography, which is constant with Siems (1996). Delong finds that the accumulative aberrant allotment (CAR) of ambition close has been added to 14.8% afterwards alliance and the behest close apart a cogent 2.2%, admitting the accumulated close neither created nor destroyed the shareholders value. The aftereffect additionally shows that the continued appellation achievement is bigger back mergers absorb inefficient bidders, acquittal not aloof fabricated by banknote and balance are not diversified.

Cybo ottone and Murgia (2000) analysed 54 better M&A deals with CARs at +3,41% amid 1988 and 1997 on the European cyberbanking area in 14 European markets. They accept begin that at the time of announcement, there was a absolute and an important admission in the bazaar bulk of the banks affianced in these deals. They accept begin absolute aberrant allotment for both buyers and the sellers application the accepted bazaar base in the abbreviate aeon of eleven days, but begin abrogating bazaar acknowledgment to accepting bank. In addition words, European coffer mergers accomplish bulk for the accumulated firms including the ambition and the bidders do not lose. Assorted studies accept apparent that in Europe and the USA, ambition shareholders acquire absolute aberrant allotment from mergers.

Cyboottone and Murgia (2000) declared that behest close shareholders acquire absolute aberrant allotment in European studies admitting in USA studies behest close shareholders acquire abrogating aberrant allotment from the mergers. Shareholders of ambition European banks accomplish added than the behest coffer shareholders, however, the aberration is actual tiny indeed. So in addition words, we can say that Cyboottone and Murgia (2000) after-effects are not constant with the USA cyberbanking abstract which shows that no bulk conception furnishings are usually found.

Martynova and Renneboog (2006) advised the abbreviate appellation abundance furnishings of 2,419 European M&A announcements amid 1993 and 2001 in twenty eight European countries. They begin that UK ambition created college allotment (9%) and UK bidders accomplished lower abundance losses (0.5%) in allegory to the absolute European boilerplate result. They additionally articular the allotment bulk acknowledgment of behest firms; on a adverse alliance i.e. it generated a abrogating aberrant acknowledgment of -0.4%, on the addition hand, a affable accretion created a absolute aberrant acknowledgment of 0.8%. Therefore, Martynova and Renneboog (2006) accept assured that M&A do actualize bulk for the behest and the ambition shareholders in which ambition shareholders adore majority of assets as they aggregate ample premiums.

Beitel (2001) attending at 98 ample M&A of European banks amid 1985 and 2000 application the accident abstraction in which he begin out, the shareholders of the ambition close adore absolute accumulative aberrant allotment (CAR), admitting the shareholders of the behest close doesn’t acquire any CARs. However, the accumulated assay of behest and ambition European coffer alliance do actualize the shareholders bulk significantly. They additionally apprehension a change in the after-effects afterwards 1998 that European behest banks in ample deals accomplished abrogating CARs and abnormally cantankerous bound mergers of European banks appeared to accept destroyed shareholders value.

Table 1: Summary of coffer mergers application accident studies of antecedent Aberrant Allotment to shareholders

M&A studies

Sample period

Sample size

Event Window

Target CARs (%)

Bidder CARs (%)

Antoniou, Arbour & Zhao (2006)



-2 to +2



Cybo-ottone & Murgia (2000)



-10 to 0


Not significant

DeLong (2001)



-10 to 1



Sudarasanam, Holl & Salami (1996)



-20to+40 days



Becher (2000)



-30 to +5



Siems (1996)



-1 to +1



Houston & Ryngaert (1997)



-2 to +2



Ismail and Davidson (2005) advised 102 alliance announcements in European cyberbanking industry amid 1987 and 1999. They begin absolute aberrant allotment for targets and the acknowledgment to bidders differs beyond the accord type, additionally the alliance deals acquire college allotment than accretion deals. They appear that the aerial antagonism in the bazaar and abridgement in the advantage in the cyberbanking industry in Europe is extending a black account of achievement of the future. They additionally appear low absolute aberrant allotment to ambition shareholders compared to addition allegation in the cyberbanking industry in Europe. The acumen abaft is that the applicant not accessible to pay college premiums in a aggressive ambiance in which akin of profits are decreasing. Ismail and Davidson (2005) pointed out that if disinterestedness is acclimated as a adjustment of acquittal instead of cash, again alliance deals acquire lower allotment because of the actuality is that disinterestedness arresting to the bazaar that the disinterestedness is overvalued which is constant with allegation of Huang and Walkling (1987).

1.7 Conclusion

A coffer acquires addition coffer because of cardinal of affidavit e.g. diversification, bazaar power, managers alternative etc. This abstract assay looks at the motives of M&A based on the accomplished bookish studies i.e. Berkovitch & Narayanan (1993), Sudarsanam et al (1996), Hannan & Pilloff (2006), Martynova & Renneboog (2006). Accepting said that, it is still not bright whether synergy assets or claimed adventure of managers is abaft affective majority of M&As. Affirmation suggests that the managers may use the chargeless banknote breeze for mergers that may aftermath abrogating NPV investments, because managers accompany their own interests rather than those of shareholders, constant in mergers to not actualize bulk for shareholders.

Whereas hubris, which supports the able bazaar antecedent (EMH) suggests that any bid for the ambition at exceptional overpays and it is aftereffect of the hubris. Arnold (2005) accompaniment it is agnate to `winner’s curse` area the accomplished applicant will bid about college than the accepted bulk of the purpose. However, best of the affirmation suggests that the ambition shareholders accretion absolute aberrant allotment while the accumulative aberrant allotment (CARs) to the bidders are decidedly abrogating and the accumulated cyberbanking firms seems to advance the shareholders value. Assorted studies additionally supports the actuality that ambition shareholders accretion at the amount of applicant shareholders and coffer mergers do not actualize bulk for the accumulated close in banal bazaar acknowledgment to coffer mergers. Also, affirmation shows that shareholders allotment are not alone afflicted by the M&A announcements but they are additionally afflicted by bid characteristics.

2.0 Methodology

2.1 Introduction

Choosing adapted assay methods are acutely vital. According to Veal (1997) it is important for the researcher to be acquainted of the ambit of methods accessible and not to accomplish claims that cannot be justified on the abject of the methods used. This allotment of this argument gives an outline how advice was collected, the sample architecture & statistics and which alignment is acclimated by apperception on European cyberbanking area mergers amid 2003 and 2007. Firstly, we accept to adjudge the aesthetics basal this research, which involves allotment a paradigm. Collis and Hussey, 2003, p. 352 ascertain paradi

Cite This Work

To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below:

Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.
Reference Copied to Clipboard.

Order a Unique Copy of this Paper